Update TF(Vision)EncoderDecoderModel PT/TF equivalence tests (#18073)

Co-authored-by: Joao Gante <joaofranciscocardosogante@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: ydshieh <ydshieh@users.noreply.github.com>

tests/models/encoder_decoder/test_modeling_tf_encoder_decoder.py

@@ -23,6 +23,7 @@ import numpy as np
 
 from transformers import is_tf_available, is_torch_available
 from transformers.testing_utils import is_pt_tf_cross_test, require_tf, require_torch, slow, torch_device
+from transformers.utils.generic import ModelOutput
 
 from ...test_modeling_tf_common import ids_tensor
 from ..bert.test_modeling_tf_bert import TFBertModelTester
@@ -326,31 +327,145 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
         )
         self.assertEqual(tuple(generated_output.shape.as_list()), (input_ids.shape[0],) + (decoder_config.max_length,))
 
-    def check_pt_tf_equivalence(self, pt_model, tf_model, inputs_dict):
+    def check_pt_tf_outputs(self, tf_outputs, pt_outputs, model_class, tol=1e-5, name="outputs", attributes=None):
+        """Check the outputs from PyTorch and TensorFlow models are close enough. Checks are done in a recursive way.
 
-        pt_model.to(torch_device)
+        Args:
-        pt_model.eval()
+            model_class: The class of the model that is currently testing. For example, `TFBertModel`,
+                TFBertForMaskedLM`, `TFBertForSequenceClassification`, etc. Mainly used for providing more informative
+                error messages.
+            name (`str`): The name of the output. For example, `output.hidden_states`, `output.attentions`, etc.
+            attributes (`Tuple[str]`): The names of the output's element if the output is a tuple/list with each element
+                being a named field in the output.
+        """
 
-        # prepare inputs
+        self.assertEqual(type(name), str)
-        tf_inputs = inputs_dict
+        if attributes is not None:
-        pt_inputs = {k: torch.tensor(v.numpy()) for k, v in tf_inputs.items()}
+            self.assertEqual(type(attributes), tuple, f"{name}: The argument `attributes` should be a `tuple`")
-        if "labels" in pt_inputs:
+
-            pt_inputs["labels"] = pt_inputs["labels"].type(torch.LongTensor)
+        # Allow `ModelOutput` (e.g. `CLIPOutput` has `text_model_output` and `vision_model_output`).
+        if isinstance(tf_outputs, ModelOutput):
+            self.assertTrue(
+                isinstance(pt_outputs, ModelOutput),
+                f"{name}: `pt_outputs` should an instance of `ModelOutput` when `tf_outputs` is",
+            )
+
+            tf_keys = [k for k, v in tf_outputs.items() if v is not None]
+            pt_keys = [k for k, v in pt_outputs.items() if v is not None]
+
+            self.assertEqual(tf_keys, pt_keys, f"{name}: Output keys differ between TF and PyTorch")
+
+            # convert to the case of `tuple`
+            # appending each key to the current (string) `names`
+            attributes = tuple([f"{name}.{k}" for k in tf_keys])
+            self.check_pt_tf_outputs(
+                tf_outputs.to_tuple(), pt_outputs.to_tuple(), model_class, tol=tol, name=name, attributes=attributes
+            )
+
+        # Allow `list` (e.g. `TransfoXLModelOutput.mems` is a list of tensors.)
+        elif type(tf_outputs) in [tuple, list]:
+            self.assertEqual(type(tf_outputs), type(pt_outputs), f"{name}: Output types differ between TF and PyTorch")
+            self.assertEqual(len(tf_outputs), len(pt_outputs), f"{name}: Output lengths differ between TF and PyTorch")
+
+            if attributes is not None:
+                # case 1: each output has assigned name (e.g. a tuple form of a `ModelOutput`)
+                self.assertEqual(
+                    len(attributes),
+                    len(tf_outputs),
+                    f"{name}: The tuple `names` should have the same length as `tf_outputs`",
+                )
+            else:
+                # case 2: each output has no assigned name (e.g. hidden states of each layer) -> add an index to `names`
+                attributes = tuple([f"{name}_{idx}" for idx in range(len(tf_outputs))])
+
+            for tf_output, pt_output, attr in zip(tf_outputs, pt_outputs, attributes):
+                self.check_pt_tf_outputs(tf_output, pt_output, model_class, tol=tol, name=attr)
+
+        elif isinstance(tf_outputs, tf.Tensor):
+            self.assertTrue(
+                isinstance(pt_outputs, torch.Tensor), f"{name}: `pt_outputs` should a tensor when `tf_outputs` is"
+            )
+
+            tf_outputs = tf_outputs.numpy()
+            pt_outputs = pt_outputs.detach().to("cpu").numpy()
+
+            self.assertEqual(
+                tf_outputs.shape, pt_outputs.shape, f"{name}: Output shapes differ between TF and PyTorch"
+            )
+
+            # deal with NumPy's scalars to make replacing nan values by 0 work.
+            if np.isscalar(tf_outputs):
+                tf_outputs = np.array([tf_outputs])
+                pt_outputs = np.array([pt_outputs])
+
+            tf_nans = np.isnan(tf_outputs)
+            pt_nans = np.isnan(pt_outputs)
+
+            pt_outputs[tf_nans] = 0
+            tf_outputs[tf_nans] = 0
+            pt_outputs[pt_nans] = 0
+            tf_outputs[pt_nans] = 0
+
+            max_diff = np.amax(np.abs(tf_outputs - pt_outputs))
+            self.assertLessEqual(max_diff, tol, f"{name}: Difference between torch and tf is {max_diff} (>= {tol}).")
+        else:
+            raise ValueError(
+                "`tf_outputs` should be an instance of `tf.Tensor`, a `tuple`, or an instance of `tf.Tensor`. Got"
+                f" {type(tf_outputs)} instead."
+            )
+
+    def prepare_pt_inputs_from_tf_inputs(self, tf_inputs_dict):
+
+        pt_inputs_dict = {}
+        for name, key in tf_inputs_dict.items():
+            if type(key) == bool:
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = key
+            elif name == "input_values":
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            elif name == "pixel_values":
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            elif name == "input_features":
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            # other general float inputs
+            elif tf_inputs_dict[name].dtype.is_floating:
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            else:
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.long)
+
+        return pt_inputs_dict
+
+    def check_pt_tf_models(self, tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict):
+
+        pt_inputs_dict = self.prepare_pt_inputs_from_tf_inputs(tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # send pytorch inputs to the correct device
-        pt_inputs = {k: v.to(device=torch_device) if isinstance(v, torch.Tensor) else v for k, v in pt_inputs.items()}
+        pt_inputs_dict = {
+            k: v.to(device=torch_device) if isinstance(v, torch.Tensor) else v for k, v in pt_inputs_dict.items()
+        }
+
+        # send pytorch model to the correct device
+        pt_model.to(torch_device)
+
+        # Check predictions on first output (logits/hidden-states) are close enough given low-level computational differences
+        pt_model.eval()
 
         with torch.no_grad():
-            pt_outputs = pt_model(**pt_inputs).to_tuple()
+            pt_outputs = pt_model(**pt_inputs_dict)
+        tf_outputs = tf_model(tf_inputs_dict)
 
-        tf_outputs = tf_model(**inputs_dict)
+        # tf models returned loss is usually a tensor rather than a scalar.
-        if "loss" in tf_outputs:
+        # (see `hf_compute_loss`: it uses `tf.keras.losses.Reduction.NONE`)
-            tf_outputs.loss = tf.math.reduce_mean(tf_outputs.loss)
+        # Change it here to a scalar to match PyTorch models' loss
-        tf_outputs = tf_outputs.to_tuple()
+        tf_loss = getattr(tf_outputs, "loss", None)
-        self.assertEqual(len(tf_outputs), len(pt_outputs), "Output lengths differ between TF and PyTorch")
+        if tf_loss is not None:
+            tf_outputs.loss = tf.math.reduce_mean(tf_loss)
 
-        for tf_output, pt_output in zip(tf_outputs, pt_outputs):
+        self.check_pt_tf_outputs(tf_outputs, pt_outputs, type(tf_model))
-            self.assert_almost_equals(tf_output.numpy(), pt_output.detach().to("cpu").numpy(), 1e-3)
+
+    def check_pt_tf_equivalence(self, tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict):
+        """Wrap `check_pt_tf_models` to further check PT -> TF again"""
+
+        self.check_pt_tf_models(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # PT -> TF
         with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as encoder_tmp_dirname, tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as decoder_tmp_dirname:
@@ -363,18 +478,16 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
             # This is only for copying some specific attributes of this particular model.
             tf_model_loaded.config = pt_model.config
 
-        tf_outputs_loaded = tf_model_loaded(**inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_tf_models(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
-        if "loss" in tf_outputs_loaded:
-            tf_outputs_loaded.loss = tf.math.reduce_mean(tf_outputs_loaded.loss)
-        tf_outputs_loaded = tf_outputs_loaded.to_tuple()
-        self.assertEqual(len(tf_outputs_loaded), len(pt_outputs), "Output lengths differ between TF and PyTorch")
 
-        for tf_output_loaded, pt_output in zip(tf_outputs_loaded, pt_outputs):
+    def check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(self, config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict):
-            self.assert_almost_equals(tf_output_loaded.numpy(), pt_output.detach().to("cpu").numpy(), 1e-3)
+        """EncoderDecoderModel requires special way to cross load (PT -> TF)"""
-
-    def check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(self, config, decoder_config, inputs_dict):
 
         encoder_decoder_config = EncoderDecoderConfig.from_encoder_decoder_configs(config, decoder_config)
+        # Output all for aggressive testing
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_hidden_states = True
+        # All models tested in this file have attentions
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_attentions = True
 
         pt_model = EncoderDecoderModel(encoder_decoder_config)
 
@@ -388,11 +501,16 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
             # This is only for copying some specific attributes of this particular model.
             tf_model.config = pt_model.config
 
-        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(pt_model, tf_model, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
 
-    def check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(self, config, decoder_config, inputs_dict):
+    def check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(self, config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict):
+        """EncoderDecoderModel requires special way to cross load (TF -> PT)"""
 
         encoder_decoder_config = EncoderDecoderConfig.from_encoder_decoder_configs(config, decoder_config)
+        # Output all for aggressive testing
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_hidden_states = True
+        # TODO: A generalizable way to determine this attribute
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_attentions = True
 
         # Using `_tf_model`, the test will fail, because the weights of `_tf_model` get extended before saving
         # the encoder/decoder models.
@@ -401,7 +519,7 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
         #   (the change in `src/transformers/modeling_tf_utils.py`)
         _tf_model = TFEncoderDecoderModel(encoder_decoder_config)
         # Make sure model is built
-        _tf_model(**inputs_dict)
+        _tf_model(**tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # Using `tf_model` to pass the test.
         encoder = _tf_model.encoder.__class__(encoder_decoder_config.encoder)
@@ -410,6 +528,7 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
         encoder(encoder.dummy_inputs)
         decoder(decoder.dummy_inputs)
         tf_model = TFEncoderDecoderModel(encoder=encoder, decoder=decoder)
+        tf_model.config = encoder_decoder_config
 
         with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as encoder_tmp_dirname, tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as decoder_tmp_dirname:
 
@@ -421,7 +540,7 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
             # This is only for copying some specific attributes of this particular model.
             pt_model.config = tf_model.config
 
-        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(pt_model, tf_model, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
 
     def test_encoder_decoder_model(self):
         input_ids_dict = self.prepare_config_and_inputs()
@@ -460,7 +579,7 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
         self.assertLessEqual(diff, tol, f"Difference between torch and tf is {diff} (>= {tol}).")
 
     @is_pt_tf_cross_test
-    def test_pt_tf_equivalence(self):
+    def test_pt_tf_model_equivalence(self):
 
         config_inputs_dict = self.prepare_config_and_inputs()
         labels = config_inputs_dict.pop("decoder_token_labels")
@@ -480,48 +599,58 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
         config = config_inputs_dict.pop("config")
         decoder_config = config_inputs_dict.pop("decoder_config")
 
-        inputs_dict = config_inputs_dict
+        # Output all for aggressive testing
+        config.output_hidden_states = True
+        decoder_config.output_hidden_states = True
+        # All models tested in this file have attentions
+        config.output_attentions = True
+        decoder_config.output_attentions = True
+
+        tf_inputs_dict = config_inputs_dict
         # `encoder_hidden_states` is not used in model call/forward
-        del inputs_dict["encoder_hidden_states"]
+        del tf_inputs_dict["encoder_hidden_states"]
 
-        inputs_dict_with_labels = copy.copy(inputs_dict)
+        # Make sure no sequence has all zeros as attention mask, otherwise some tests fail due to the inconsistency
-        inputs_dict_with_labels["labels"] = labels
+        # of the usage `1e-4`, `1e-9`, `1e-30`, `-inf`.
+        for k in ["attention_mask", "decoder_attention_mask"]:
+            attention_mask = tf_inputs_dict[k]
 
-        # Avoid the case where a sequence has no place to attend (after combined with the causal attention mask)
+            # Make sure no all 0s attention masks - to avoid failure at this moment.
-        batch_size = inputs_dict["decoder_attention_mask"].shape[0]
+            # Put `1` at the beginning of sequences to make it still work when combining causal attention masks.
-        inputs_dict["decoder_attention_mask"] = tf.constant(
+            # TODO: remove this line once a fix regarding large negative values for attention mask is done.
-            np.concatenate([np.ones(shape=(batch_size, 1)), inputs_dict["decoder_attention_mask"][:, 1:]], axis=1)
+            attention_mask = tf.concat(
+                [tf.ones_like(attention_mask[:, :1], dtype=attention_mask.dtype), attention_mask[:, 1:]], axis=-1
             )
+            tf_inputs_dict[k] = attention_mask
 
-        # TF models don't use the `use_cache` option and cache is not returned as a default.
+        tf_inputs_dict_with_labels = copy.copy(tf_inputs_dict)
-        # So we disable `use_cache` here for PyTorch model.
+        tf_inputs_dict_with_labels["labels"] = labels
-        decoder_config.use_cache = False
 
         self.assertTrue(decoder_config.cross_attention_hidden_size is None)
 
-        # check without `enc_to_dec_proj` projection
+        # Original test: check without `labels` and  without `enc_to_dec_proj` projection
         self.assertTrue(config.hidden_size == decoder_config.hidden_size)
-        self.check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
-        self.check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
 
-        # check equivalence with labels
+        # check with `labels`
-        self.check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict_with_labels)
+        self.check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict_with_labels)
-        self.check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict_with_labels)
+        self.check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict_with_labels)
 
         # This is not working, because pt/tf equivalence test for encoder-decoder use `from_encoder_decoder_pretrained`,
         # which randomly initialize `enc_to_dec_proj`.
-        # # check `enc_to_dec_proj` work as expected
+        # check `enc_to_dec_proj` work as expected
         # decoder_config.hidden_size = decoder_config.hidden_size * 2
         # self.assertTrue(config.hidden_size != decoder_config.hidden_size)
-        # self.check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        # self.check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
-        # self.check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        # self.check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # Let's just check `enc_to_dec_proj` can run for now
         decoder_config.hidden_size = decoder_config.hidden_size * 2
         self.assertTrue(config.hidden_size != decoder_config.hidden_size)
         encoder_decoder_config = EncoderDecoderConfig.from_encoder_decoder_configs(config, decoder_config)
         model = TFEncoderDecoderModel(encoder_decoder_config)
-        model(**inputs_dict)
+        model(tf_inputs_dict)
 
     def test_model_save_load_from_pretrained(self):
         model_2 = self.get_pretrained_model()
@@ -554,6 +683,10 @@ class TFEncoderDecoderMixin:
 
 @require_tf
 class TFBertEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
+    def setUp(self):
+        self.encoder_model_tester = TFBertModelTester(self, batch_size=13)
+        self.decoder_model_tester = TFBertModelTester(self, batch_size=13)
+
     def get_pretrained_model(self):
         return TFEncoderDecoderModel.from_encoder_decoder_pretrained(
             "hf-internal-testing/tiny-random-bert",
@@ -566,10 +699,8 @@ class TFBertEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
         return encoder_model, decoder_model
 
     def prepare_config_and_inputs(self):
-        model_tester_encoder = TFBertModelTester(self, batch_size=13)
+        encoder_config_and_inputs = self.encoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        model_tester_decoder = TFBertModelTester(self, batch_size=13)
+        decoder_config_and_inputs = self.decoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
-        encoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_encoder.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        decoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_decoder.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
         (
             config,
             input_ids,
@@ -652,6 +783,10 @@ class TFBertEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
 
 @require_tf
 class TFGPT2EncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
+    def setUp(self):
+        self.encoder_model_tester = TFBertModelTester(self, batch_size=13)
+        self.decoder_model_tester = TFGPT2ModelTester(self)
+
     def get_pretrained_model(self):
         return TFEncoderDecoderModel.from_encoder_decoder_pretrained(
             "hf-internal-testing/tiny-random-bert",
@@ -664,10 +799,8 @@ class TFGPT2EncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
         return encoder_model, decoder_model
 
     def prepare_config_and_inputs(self):
-        model_tester_encoder = TFBertModelTester(self, batch_size=13)
+        encoder_config_and_inputs = self.encoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        model_tester_decoder = TFGPT2ModelTester(self)
+        decoder_config_and_inputs = self.decoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
-        encoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_encoder.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        decoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_decoder.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
         (
             config,
             input_ids,
@@ -744,6 +877,10 @@ class TFGPT2EncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
 
 @require_tf
 class TFRoBertaEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
+    def setUp(self):
+        self.encoder_model_tester = TFRobertaModelTester(self)
+        self.decoder_model_tester = TFRobertaModelTester(self)
+
     def get_pretrained_model(self):
         return TFEncoderDecoderModel.from_encoder_decoder_pretrained(
             "hf-internal-testing/tiny-random-roberta",
@@ -756,10 +893,8 @@ class TFRoBertaEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase)
         return encoder_model, decoder_model
 
     def prepare_config_and_inputs(self):
-        model_tester_encoder = TFRobertaModelTester(self)
+        encoder_config_and_inputs = self.encoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        model_tester_decoder = TFRobertaModelTester(self)
+        decoder_config_and_inputs = self.decoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
-        encoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_encoder.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        decoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_decoder.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
         (
             config,
             input_ids,
@@ -803,6 +938,10 @@ class TFRoBertaEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase)
 
 @require_tf
 class TFRembertEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase):
+    def setUp(self):
+        self.encoder_model_tester = TFRemBertModelTester(self)
+        self.decoder_model_tester = TFRemBertModelTester(self)
+
     def get_pretrained_model(self):
         return TFEncoderDecoderModel.from_encoder_decoder_pretrained(
             "hf-internal-testing/tiny-random-rembert",
@@ -815,10 +954,8 @@ class TFRembertEncoderDecoderModelTest(TFEncoderDecoderMixin, unittest.TestCase)
         return encoder_model, decoder_model
 
     def prepare_config_and_inputs(self):
-        model_tester_encoder = TFRemBertModelTester(self)
+        encoder_config_and_inputs = self.encoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        model_tester_decoder = TFRemBertModelTester(self)
+        decoder_config_and_inputs = self.decoder_model_tester.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
-        encoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_encoder.prepare_config_and_inputs()
-        decoder_config_and_inputs = model_tester_decoder.prepare_config_and_inputs_for_decoder()
         (
             config,
             input_ids,

tests/models/vision_encoder_decoder/test_modeling_tf_vision_encoder_decoder.py

@@ -31,6 +31,7 @@ from transformers.testing_utils import (
     slow,
     torch_device,
 )
+from transformers.utils.generic import ModelOutput
 
 from ...test_modeling_tf_common import floats_tensor, ids_tensor
 from ..gpt2.test_modeling_tf_gpt2 import TFGPT2ModelTester
@@ -314,31 +315,145 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
             tuple(generated_output.shape.as_list()), (pixel_values.shape[0],) + (decoder_config.max_length,)
         )
 
-    def check_pt_tf_equivalence(self, pt_model, tf_model, inputs_dict):
+    def check_pt_tf_outputs(self, tf_outputs, pt_outputs, model_class, tol=1e-5, name="outputs", attributes=None):
+        """Check the outputs from PyTorch and TensorFlow models are close enough. Checks are done in a recursive way.
 
-        pt_model.to(torch_device)
+        Args:
-        pt_model.eval()
+            model_class: The class of the model that is currently testing. For example, `TFBertModel`,
+                TFBertForMaskedLM`, `TFBertForSequenceClassification`, etc. Mainly used for providing more informative
+                error messages.
+            name (`str`): The name of the output. For example, `output.hidden_states`, `output.attentions`, etc.
+            attributes (`Tuple[str]`): The names of the output's element if the output is a tuple/list with each element
+                being a named field in the output.
+        """
 
-        # prepare inputs
+        self.assertEqual(type(name), str)
-        tf_inputs = inputs_dict
+        if attributes is not None:
-        pt_inputs = {k: torch.tensor(v.numpy()) for k, v in tf_inputs.items()}
+            self.assertEqual(type(attributes), tuple, f"{name}: The argument `attributes` should be a `tuple`")
-        if "labels" in pt_inputs:
+
-            pt_inputs["labels"] = pt_inputs["labels"].type(torch.LongTensor)
+        # Allow `ModelOutput` (e.g. `CLIPOutput` has `text_model_output` and `vision_model_output`).
+        if isinstance(tf_outputs, ModelOutput):
+            self.assertTrue(
+                isinstance(pt_outputs, ModelOutput),
+                f"{name}: `pt_outputs` should an instance of `ModelOutput` when `tf_outputs` is",
+            )
+
+            tf_keys = [k for k, v in tf_outputs.items() if v is not None]
+            pt_keys = [k for k, v in pt_outputs.items() if v is not None]
+
+            self.assertEqual(tf_keys, pt_keys, f"{name}: Output keys differ between TF and PyTorch")
+
+            # convert to the case of `tuple`
+            # appending each key to the current (string) `names`
+            attributes = tuple([f"{name}.{k}" for k in tf_keys])
+            self.check_pt_tf_outputs(
+                tf_outputs.to_tuple(), pt_outputs.to_tuple(), model_class, tol=tol, name=name, attributes=attributes
+            )
+
+        # Allow `list` (e.g. `TransfoXLModelOutput.mems` is a list of tensors.)
+        elif type(tf_outputs) in [tuple, list]:
+            self.assertEqual(type(tf_outputs), type(pt_outputs), f"{name}: Output types differ between TF and PyTorch")
+            self.assertEqual(len(tf_outputs), len(pt_outputs), f"{name}: Output lengths differ between TF and PyTorch")
+
+            if attributes is not None:
+                # case 1: each output has assigned name (e.g. a tuple form of a `ModelOutput`)
+                self.assertEqual(
+                    len(attributes),
+                    len(tf_outputs),
+                    f"{name}: The tuple `names` should have the same length as `tf_outputs`",
+                )
+            else:
+                # case 2: each output has no assigned name (e.g. hidden states of each layer) -> add an index to `names`
+                attributes = tuple([f"{name}_{idx}" for idx in range(len(tf_outputs))])
+
+            for tf_output, pt_output, attr in zip(tf_outputs, pt_outputs, attributes):
+                self.check_pt_tf_outputs(tf_output, pt_output, model_class, tol=tol, name=attr)
+
+        elif isinstance(tf_outputs, tf.Tensor):
+            self.assertTrue(
+                isinstance(pt_outputs, torch.Tensor), f"{name}: `pt_outputs` should a tensor when `tf_outputs` is"
+            )
+
+            tf_outputs = tf_outputs.numpy()
+            pt_outputs = pt_outputs.detach().to("cpu").numpy()
+
+            self.assertEqual(
+                tf_outputs.shape, pt_outputs.shape, f"{name}: Output shapes differ between TF and PyTorch"
+            )
+
+            # deal with NumPy's scalars to make replacing nan values by 0 work.
+            if np.isscalar(tf_outputs):
+                tf_outputs = np.array([tf_outputs])
+                pt_outputs = np.array([pt_outputs])
+
+            tf_nans = np.isnan(tf_outputs)
+            pt_nans = np.isnan(pt_outputs)
+
+            pt_outputs[tf_nans] = 0
+            tf_outputs[tf_nans] = 0
+            pt_outputs[pt_nans] = 0
+            tf_outputs[pt_nans] = 0
+
+            max_diff = np.amax(np.abs(tf_outputs - pt_outputs))
+            self.assertLessEqual(max_diff, tol, f"{name}: Difference between torch and tf is {max_diff} (>= {tol}).")
+        else:
+            raise ValueError(
+                "`tf_outputs` should be an instance of `tf.Tensor`, a `tuple`, or an instance of `tf.Tensor`. Got"
+                f" {type(tf_outputs)} instead."
+            )
+
+    def prepare_pt_inputs_from_tf_inputs(self, tf_inputs_dict):
+
+        pt_inputs_dict = {}
+        for name, key in tf_inputs_dict.items():
+            if type(key) == bool:
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = key
+            elif name == "input_values":
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            elif name == "pixel_values":
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            elif name == "input_features":
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            # other general float inputs
+            elif tf_inputs_dict[name].dtype.is_floating:
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.float32)
+            else:
+                pt_inputs_dict[name] = torch.from_numpy(key.numpy()).to(torch.long)
+
+        return pt_inputs_dict
+
+    def check_pt_tf_models(self, tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict):
+
+        pt_inputs_dict = self.prepare_pt_inputs_from_tf_inputs(tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # send pytorch inputs to the correct device
-        pt_inputs = {k: v.to(device=torch_device) if isinstance(v, torch.Tensor) else v for k, v in pt_inputs.items()}
+        pt_inputs_dict = {
+            k: v.to(device=torch_device) if isinstance(v, torch.Tensor) else v for k, v in pt_inputs_dict.items()
+        }
+
+        # send pytorch model to the correct device
+        pt_model.to(torch_device)
+
+        # Check predictions on first output (logits/hidden-states) are close enough given low-level computational differences
+        pt_model.eval()
 
         with torch.no_grad():
-            pt_outputs = pt_model(**pt_inputs).to_tuple()
+            pt_outputs = pt_model(**pt_inputs_dict)
+        tf_outputs = tf_model(tf_inputs_dict)
 
-        tf_outputs = tf_model(**inputs_dict)
+        # tf models returned loss is usually a tensor rather than a scalar.
-        if "loss" in tf_outputs:
+        # (see `hf_compute_loss`: it uses `tf.keras.losses.Reduction.NONE`)
-            tf_outputs.loss = tf.math.reduce_mean(tf_outputs.loss)
+        # Change it here to a scalar to match PyTorch models' loss
-        tf_outputs = tf_outputs.to_tuple()
+        tf_loss = getattr(tf_outputs, "loss", None)
-        self.assertEqual(len(tf_outputs), len(pt_outputs), "Output lengths differ between TF and PyTorch")
+        if tf_loss is not None:
+            tf_outputs.loss = tf.math.reduce_mean(tf_loss)
 
-        for tf_output, pt_output in zip(tf_outputs, pt_outputs):
+        self.check_pt_tf_outputs(tf_outputs, pt_outputs, type(tf_model))
-            self.assert_almost_equals(tf_output.numpy(), pt_output.detach().to("cpu").numpy(), 1e-3)
+
+    def check_pt_tf_equivalence(self, tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict):
+        """Wrap `check_pt_tf_models` to further check PT -> TF again"""
+
+        self.check_pt_tf_models(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # PT -> TF
         with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as encoder_tmp_dirname, tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as decoder_tmp_dirname:
@@ -351,18 +466,16 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
             # This is only for copying some specific attributes of this particular model.
             tf_model_loaded.config = pt_model.config
 
-        tf_outputs_loaded = tf_model_loaded(**inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_tf_models(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
-        if "loss" in tf_outputs_loaded:
-            tf_outputs_loaded.loss = tf.math.reduce_mean(tf_outputs_loaded.loss)
-        tf_outputs_loaded = tf_outputs_loaded.to_tuple()
-        self.assertEqual(len(tf_outputs_loaded), len(pt_outputs), "Output lengths differ between TF and PyTorch")
 
-        for tf_output_loaded, pt_output in zip(tf_outputs_loaded, pt_outputs):
+    def check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(self, config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict):
-            self.assert_almost_equals(tf_output_loaded.numpy(), pt_output.detach().to("cpu").numpy(), 1e-3)
+        """EncoderDecoderModel requires special way to cross load (PT -> TF)"""
-
-    def check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(self, config, decoder_config, inputs_dict):
 
         encoder_decoder_config = VisionEncoderDecoderConfig.from_encoder_decoder_configs(config, decoder_config)
+        # Output all for aggressive testing
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_hidden_states = True
+        # All models tested in this file have attentions
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_attentions = True
 
         pt_model = VisionEncoderDecoderModel(encoder_decoder_config)
 
@@ -376,11 +489,16 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
             # This is only for copying some specific attributes of this particular model.
             tf_model.config = pt_model.config
 
-        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(pt_model, tf_model, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
 
-    def check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(self, config, decoder_config, inputs_dict):
+    def check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(self, config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict):
+        """EncoderDecoderModel requires special way to cross load (TF -> PT)"""
 
         encoder_decoder_config = VisionEncoderDecoderConfig.from_encoder_decoder_configs(config, decoder_config)
+        # Output all for aggressive testing
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_hidden_states = True
+        # TODO: A generalizable way to determine this attribute
+        encoder_decoder_config.output_attentions = True
 
         # Using `_tf_model`, the test will fail, because the weights of `_tf_model` get extended before saving
         # the encoder/decoder models.
@@ -389,7 +507,7 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
         #   (the change in `src/transformers/modeling_tf_utils.py`)
         _tf_model = TFVisionEncoderDecoderModel(encoder_decoder_config)
         # Make sure model is built
-        _tf_model(**inputs_dict)
+        _tf_model(**tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # Using `tf_model` to pass the test.
         encoder = _tf_model.encoder.__class__(encoder_decoder_config.encoder)
@@ -398,6 +516,7 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
         encoder(encoder.dummy_inputs)
         decoder(decoder.dummy_inputs)
         tf_model = TFVisionEncoderDecoderModel(encoder=encoder, decoder=decoder)
+        tf_model.config = encoder_decoder_config
 
         with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as encoder_tmp_dirname, tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as decoder_tmp_dirname:
 
@@ -409,7 +528,7 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
             # This is only for copying some specific attributes of this particular model.
             pt_model.config = tf_model.config
 
-        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(pt_model, tf_model, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_tf_equivalence(tf_model, pt_model, tf_inputs_dict)
 
     def test_encoder_decoder_model(self):
         config_inputs_dict = self.prepare_config_and_inputs()
@@ -448,7 +567,7 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
         self.assertLessEqual(diff, tol, f"Difference between torch and tf is {diff} (>= {tol}).")
 
     @is_pt_tf_cross_test
-    def test_pt_tf_equivalence(self):
+    def test_pt_tf_model_equivalence(self):
 
         config_inputs_dict = self.prepare_config_and_inputs()
         labels = config_inputs_dict.pop("decoder_token_labels")
@@ -467,48 +586,58 @@ class TFVisionEncoderDecoderMixin:
         config = config_inputs_dict.pop("config")
         decoder_config = config_inputs_dict.pop("decoder_config")
 
-        inputs_dict = config_inputs_dict
+        # Output all for aggressive testing
+        config.output_hidden_states = True
+        decoder_config.output_hidden_states = True
+        # All models tested in this file have attentions
+        config.output_attentions = True
+        decoder_config.output_attentions = True
+
+        tf_inputs_dict = config_inputs_dict
         # `encoder_hidden_states` is not used in model call/forward
-        del inputs_dict["encoder_hidden_states"]
+        del tf_inputs_dict["encoder_hidden_states"]
 
-        inputs_dict_with_labels = copy.copy(inputs_dict)
+        # Make sure no sequence has all zeros as attention mask, otherwise some tests fail due to the inconsistency
-        inputs_dict_with_labels["labels"] = labels
+        # of the usage `1e-4`, `1e-9`, `1e-30`, `-inf`.
+        for k in ["decoder_attention_mask"]:
+            attention_mask = tf_inputs_dict[k]
 
-        # Avoid the case where a sequence has no place to attend (after combined with the causal attention mask)
+            # Make sure no all 0s attention masks - to avoid failure at this moment.
-        batch_size = inputs_dict["decoder_attention_mask"].shape[0]
+            # Put `1` at the beginning of sequences to make it still work when combining causal attention masks.
-        inputs_dict["decoder_attention_mask"] = tf.constant(
+            # TODO: remove this line once a fix regarding large negative values for attention mask is done.
-            np.concatenate([np.ones(shape=(batch_size, 1)), inputs_dict["decoder_attention_mask"][:, 1:]], axis=1)
+            attention_mask = tf.concat(
+                [tf.ones_like(attention_mask[:, :1], dtype=attention_mask.dtype), attention_mask[:, 1:]], axis=-1
             )
+            tf_inputs_dict[k] = attention_mask
 
-        # TF models don't use the `use_cache` option and cache is not returned as a default.
+        tf_inputs_dict_with_labels = copy.copy(tf_inputs_dict)
-        # So we disable `use_cache` here for PyTorch model.
+        tf_inputs_dict_with_labels["labels"] = labels
-        decoder_config.use_cache = False
 
         self.assertTrue(decoder_config.cross_attention_hidden_size is None)
 
-        # check without `enc_to_dec_proj` projection
+        # Original test: check without `labels` and  without `enc_to_dec_proj` projection
         self.assertTrue(config.hidden_size == decoder_config.hidden_size)
-        self.check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
-        self.check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        self.check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
 
-        # check equivalence with labels
+        # check with `labels`
-        self.check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict_with_labels)
+        self.check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict_with_labels)
-        self.check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict_with_labels)
+        self.check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict_with_labels)
 
         # This is not working, because pt/tf equivalence test for encoder-decoder use `from_encoder_decoder_pretrained`,
         # which randomly initialize `enc_to_dec_proj`.
-        # # check `enc_to_dec_proj` work as expected
+        # check `enc_to_dec_proj` work as expected
         # decoder_config.hidden_size = decoder_config.hidden_size * 2
         # self.assertTrue(config.hidden_size != decoder_config.hidden_size)
-        # self.check_equivalence_pt_to_tf(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        # self.check_pt_to_tf_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
-        # self.check_equivalence_tf_to_pt(config, decoder_config, inputs_dict)
+        # self.check_tf_to_pt_equivalence(config, decoder_config, tf_inputs_dict)
 
         # Let's just check `enc_to_dec_proj` can run for now
         decoder_config.hidden_size = decoder_config.hidden_size * 2
         self.assertTrue(config.hidden_size != decoder_config.hidden_size)
         encoder_decoder_config = VisionEncoderDecoderConfig.from_encoder_decoder_configs(config, decoder_config)
         model = TFVisionEncoderDecoderModel(encoder_decoder_config)
-        model(**inputs_dict)
+        model(tf_inputs_dict)
 
     @slow
     def test_real_model_save_load_from_pretrained(self):

tests/test_modeling_common.py

@@ -1616,7 +1616,7 @@ class ModelTesterMixin:
 
     # Copied from tests.test_modeling_tf_common.TFModelTesterMixin.check_pt_tf_outputs
     def check_pt_tf_outputs(self, tf_outputs, pt_outputs, model_class, tol=1e-5, name="outputs", attributes=None):
-        """Check the outputs from PyTorch and TensorFlow models are closed enough. Checks are done in a recursive way.
+        """Check the outputs from PyTorch and TensorFlow models are close enough. Checks are done in a recursive way.
 
         Args:
             model_class: The class of the model that is currently testing. For example, `TFBertModel`,
@@ -1642,8 +1642,8 @@ class ModelTesterMixin:
             # TODO: remove this method and this line after issues are fixed
             tf_outputs, pt_outputs = self._postprocessing_to_ignore_test_cases(tf_outputs, pt_outputs, model_class)
 
-            tf_keys = tuple([k for k, v in tf_outputs.items() if v is not None])
+            tf_keys = [k for k, v in tf_outputs.items() if v is not None]
-            pt_keys = tuple([k for k, v in pt_outputs.items() if v is not None])
+            pt_keys = [k for k, v in pt_outputs.items() if v is not None]
 
             self.assertEqual(tf_keys, pt_keys, f"{name}: Output keys differ between TF and PyTorch")
 

tests/test_modeling_tf_common.py

@@ -428,7 +428,7 @@ class TFModelTesterMixin:
         return new_tf_outputs, new_pt_outputs
 
     def check_pt_tf_outputs(self, tf_outputs, pt_outputs, model_class, tol=1e-5, name="outputs", attributes=None):
-        """Check the outputs from PyTorch and TensorFlow models are closed enough. Checks are done in a recursive way.
+        """Check the outputs from PyTorch and TensorFlow models are close enough. Checks are done in a recursive way.
 
         Args:
             model_class: The class of the model that is currently testing. For example, `TFBertModel`,
@@ -454,8 +454,8 @@ class TFModelTesterMixin:
             # TODO: remove this method and this line after issues are fixed
             tf_outputs, pt_outputs = self._postprocessing_to_ignore_test_cases(tf_outputs, pt_outputs, model_class)
 
-            tf_keys = tuple([k for k, v in tf_outputs.items() if v is not None])
+            tf_keys = [k for k, v in tf_outputs.items() if v is not None]
-            pt_keys = tuple([k for k, v in pt_outputs.items() if v is not None])
+            pt_keys = [k for k, v in pt_outputs.items() if v is not None]
 
             self.assertEqual(tf_keys, pt_keys, f"{name}: Output keys differ between TF and PyTorch")